Prada · Reviewed by Courtney B Luxe · Published 2026-09-05
Based on a review by Courtney B Luxe (accessed 2026-09-05).
Based on this review alone: buy it if you care about eyeshadow formula is silky smooth, creamy, and effortless to work with — just accept new lipstick shades (spice mahogany, mahogany brick) are very similar to existing prada lip colors (mahogany, quartz).
The reviewer concluded that the entire Prada Mahogany collection is special and beautiful, living up to her high expectations for Prada's quality. She finds the eyeshadow palette particularly gorgeous and easy to work with, while praising the luxurious, hydrating formula of the lipsticks.
This video reviews the new Prada Mahogany collection, featuring a detailed look at the eyeshadow palette and two new lipstick shades. The reviewer provides swatches and demonstrates the application of the eyeshadows and lipsticks to showcase their performance.
This Prada Mahogany Eyeshadow Palette is highly recommended for its exceptional formula and stunning fall-themed color story. The eyeshadow formula is incredibly silky smooth, creamy, and blends out effortlessly, making it user-friendly for creating various looks without major fallout. However, the new Mahogany collection lipsticks are notably similar to existing Prada shades, such as Mahogany and Quartz, which may disappoint those seeking unique new colors. If you are a fan of rich, warm fall tones and appreciate a luxurious, easy-to-work-with eyeshadow formula, this palette is a fantastic addition. However, if you already own Prada's classic mahogany or similar nude lipsticks, you might want to consider skipping the new lipstick releases.
reviewer_claimstrong
reviewer_claimmoderate
specification_claimstrong
reviewer_claimstrong
comparison_claimstrong
reviewer_claimstrong
reviewer_claimstrong
reviewer_claimpositive
The reviewer states that the Prada eyeshadow formula is silky smooth and that this particular palette is very special. She also noted it's creamy, smooth, and effortless to work with, blending out nicely.
visual_inspectionneutral
The iridescent shade, appearing white in the pan, is described as having a golden peach iridescence when applied, making sense within the palette's color story.
visual_inspectionpositive
The reviewer notes that Prada maintained its beautiful original luxury packaging for the eyeshadow palette, contrasting it with previous blush packaging.
hands_on_demopositive
The reviewer demonstrates the ease of blending with the eyeshadows, describing the formula as foolproof and flawless, with no major fallout detected apart from a little shimmer.
specification_claimneutral
The Prada Pradascope Mascara has a unique wand design with bristles on only one side.
reviewer_claimpositive
The reviewer states the Prada mascara is 'really great' and 'underrated,' showing its effect with one or two coats.
hands_on_demoneutral
The reviewer swatches both existing Prada lipstick shades (Quartz, Mahogany) and the two new shades (Spice Mahogany, Mahogany Brick) on her arm.
comparisonmixed
The reviewer notes that the new Mahogany Brick lipstick looks 'pretty similar' to the original Prada Mahogany shade, questioning if there's a major difference and suggesting Mahogany Brick might be slightly deeper or more brown-toned.
reviewer_claimpositive
The Prada lipstick formula, including both soft matte and hyper matte, is described as incredibly luxurious, blurring, and creamy, emphasizing that it is not a dry matte.
hands_on_demopositive
Upon applying Spice Mahogany, the reviewer praises its creamy formula and notes that it feels incredibly hydrating and blurring on the lips.
hands_on_demopositive
The reviewer applies Mahogany Brick, a hyper matte, and highlights that despite being matte, it is incredibly creamy, hydrating, and does not show lines on the lips, making it a 'really good matte formula'.
reviewer_claimpositive
The reviewer states that Prada eyeliners are 'incredibly creamy' and 'don't tug on the eye', describing the Mahogany eyeliner as a 'great formula'.
hands_on_demopositive
The reviewer swatches the Prada Mahogany eyeliner on her arm, calling it 'really beautiful' and a great shade for fall.
The reviewer consistently praised the eyeshadow formula, noting it is silky smooth, creamy, effortless to apply, and blends out nicely with no major fallout. She found the colors beautiful and perfect for fall, specifically highlighting how the iridescent shade transforms from white in the pan to a golden-peach tint on the skin.
The reviewer compared the new Mahogany Brick hyper matte lipstick to the original Prada Mahogany shade and found them to be very similar, with Mahogany Brick possibly being slightly deeper or having more of a brown undertone. She suggested that if you already own the original Mahogany, you might consider skipping Mahogany Brick. Spice Mahogany was presented as a nice, hydrating neutral that complements the bold eyeshadow palette.
The reviewer emphasized that both the soft matte (Spice Mahogany) and hyper matte (Mahogany Brick) formulas are incredibly luxurious, blurring, and creamy, notably not feeling dry. She specifically stated that even individuals typically averse to matte lipsticks would likely enjoy Prada's formulas due to their hydrating nature and ability to not show lines on the lips.
The reviewer highly recommended Prada eyeliners, stating that they are 'incredibly creamy' and 'don't tug on the eye.' She highlighted that the Mahogany eyeliner, which she had purchased previously, is a beautiful shade and a great formula overall.
The reviewer found the Prada mascara to be a 'really great mascara' and 'underrated.' She mentioned its unique wand design, featuring bristles on only one side, which she personally liked, noting it provided good coverage after one or two coats.
60/100 source quality
In this review, Courtney B Luxe explores the new Prada Mahogany collection, showcasing the eyeshadow palette and two new lipstick shades: Spice Mahogany (soft matte) and Mahogany Brick (hyper matte). She provides swatches and demonstrates the eyeshadow palette's application, highlighting its creamy, blendable formula and fall-appropriate colors. The reviewer also compares the new Mahogany Brick lipstick to an existing Prada Mahogany shade, noting their similarities, and praises the hydrating, non-drying nature of the matte lipstick formulas. Additionally, she briefly reviews a Prada mascara and eyeliner.
Full transcript is not redistributed here to respect the original creator’s rights.
This page converts Courtney B Luxe's review of the Prada Prada Mahogany Eyeshadow Palette into structured evidence — timestamped claims, pros & cons, and buyer questions. It is not the original review and does not replace watching or reading the full source.
Brand relationship disclosed as: affiliate