Rhode · Reviewed by Robert Welsh · Published 2026-07-14
Based on a review by Robert Welsh (accessed 2026-07-14).
Based on this review alone: worth considering for feels very lightweight on the skin, but contains tiny flecks of glitter is a real trade-off.
The reviewer concluded that while some products like the Cheery Up eyeshadow palette and the reformulated TIRTIR foundation performed well, others like the Rhode Highlight Milk contained glitter, which he disliked. He found the Rhode Pocket Bronze to be nice but not revolutionary, ultimately recommending specific shades for contouring.
The review evaluates six "overhyped" makeup products, including items from Rhode, TIRTIR, Half Magic, Dior, and Cheri Up. The reviewer conducts hands-on demonstrations and provides opinions on their performance, coverage, texture, and suitability for different skin types and preferences. The video aims to determine if these viral products live up to their online hype.
The Rhode Highlight Milk Multi-Purpose Illuminizer is a satisfactory glowy product for those tolerant of subtle shimmer, but it ultimately fails to deliver a true "glow from within" effect. It feels extremely lightweight on the skin and avoids greasiness, which are definite positives. However, the reviewer observed distinct, tiny flecks of glitter, particularly visible in direct sunlight, contradicting the desired natural sheen. If you are comfortable with a lightweight illuminizer that has a subtle glitter and a pink undertone, this product might be suitable. If you prefer a truly seamless, non-glittery radiance, you should explore other options.
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimstrong
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimstrong
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimmoderate
reviewer_claimstrong
reviewer_claimmoderate
measurement_testnegativet=2:30–2:55
The reviewer applies the Rhode Highlight Milk and states that while it looks more shiny than glittery, he can see the smallest flecks of glitter, especially when tested in direct sunlight.
hands_on_demopositivet=2:04–2:10
The reviewer describes the Rhode Highlight Milk as very lightweight, not too heavy on the skin, and not over-hydrating. He feels it will provide a glow without being greasy.
hands_on_demopositivet=4:00–4:05
During application, the reviewer notes that the Cheery Up eyeshadow palette blends beautifully and is very easy to work with, indicating a nice formula.
hands_on_demonegativet=4:40–4:55
The reviewer observes that one of the purple pastel shades in the Cheery Up palette did not build up well on the inside corner of his eye, losing its pigment and requiring a specific application technique.
visual_inspectionnegativet=3:50–3:58
The reviewer points out chunky, star-shaped glitter sequin pieces in the Cheery Up palette that he would never use because he hates glitter, describing them as "as chunky as that is."
hands_on_demoneutralt=7:10–7:15
The reviewer doesn't notice too much difference in coverage compared to the previous TIRTIR Red Cushion formula, stating it still provides good coverage.
hands_on_demopositivet=7:15–7:30
The reviewer finds the new TIRTIR Red Cushion formula allows for more buildability, going on "a little bit more relaxed" compared to the previous version which required more caution.
reviewer_claimpositivet=7:40–7:50
The reviewer notes the texture of the reformulated TIRTIR Red Cushion feels lighter, not going on as heavy or fast as the previous version, while still moving nicely with his skin.
hands_on_demopositivet=9:35–9:50
Applying the Pebble shade of the Rhode Pocket Bronze, the reviewer finds it very sculpting and describes it as borderline contour, looking like a natural shadow on his skin.
visual_inspectionnegativet=9:15–9:20
The reviewer states that the Zip shade of the Rhode Pocket Bronze appears orange on his skin tone during the visual comparison of the sticks and upon initial application.
The reviewer noted that despite appearing more shiny than glittery, the Rhode Highlight Milk does have small flecks of glitter visible, particularly when viewed in direct sunlight. This was a drawback for the reviewer, who prefers a non-glittery glow.
The reviewer found that the Cheery Up eyeshadow palette offers a nice formula that blends beautifully and is easy to work with. However, he noted that some pastel shades, specifically a purple in the inner corner, did not build up well without losing pigment, requiring careful application.
The reviewer observed that the reformulated TIRTIR Mask Fit Red Cushion maintains similar coverage to its predecessor. The most notable improvements are its increased buildability, allowing for a more relaxed application, and a lighter feel on the skin, preventing it from going on as heavily or quickly as the original.
The reviewer found the Rhode Pocket Bronze in the shade Pebble to be very sculpting and borderline contour. He noted that it creates a natural shadow effect on his skin, making it a good choice for contouring, especially for fairer skin tones.
100/100 source quality
Robert Welsh reviews six highly hyped makeup products, sharing his "brutal honesty" on whether they live up to the online buzz. He tests the Rhode Highlight Milk for glow and glitter content, the Cheery Up eyeshadow palette for pigment and blendability, the reformulated TIRTIR Red Cushion for coverage and feel, and the Rhode Pocket Bronze for contouring and bronzing effects. He offers personal opinions on each product's performance, highlighting both pros and cons based on his experience and preferences.
Full transcript is not redistributed here to respect the original creator’s rights.
This page converts Robert Welsh's review of the Rhode Highlight Milk Multi-Purpose Illuminizer into structured evidence — timestamped claims, pros & cons, and buyer questions. It is not the original review and does not replace watching or reading the full source.
Brand relationship disclosed as: affiliate